Plz help me
17 Apr 2015 23:14
manishmodi
Member@gv sir
Kya tum market gaye the?
Had you gone to market
Kya tumne electricity bill diya tha?
Had you given electricity bill
Is it correct? ??
Because few teachers on this forum are saying it is right and few are saying it is wrong
"Sakshi"
ModeratorKya tum market gaye the?
1. Had you gone to market?
—Did you go to the market?
Kya tumne electricity bill diya tha?
2.Had you given electricity bill?
—Did you give the electricity bill?
Because few teachers on this forum are saying it is right and few are saying it is wrong.
—No teacher is here but learner. If you follow the grammar rules, then you should not have asked this question. As per Past Perfect definition, 1 and 2 don’t fit there. I would rather say it ungrammatical than wrong.
[/quote]
TS
MemberKya tum market gaye the?
1. Had you gone to market?
—Did you go to the market?Kya tumne electricity bill diya tha?
2.Had you given electricity bill?
—Did you give the electricity bill?Because few teachers on this forum are saying it is right and few are saying it is wrong.
—No teacher is here but learner. If you follow the grammar rules, then you should not have asked this question. As per Past Perfect definition, 1 and 2 don’t fit there. I would rather say it ungrammatical than wrong.
Sentences depand on situations.
Jab main waha geya to us ne bill de diya tha.
When I went there, Then He had given the bill.
Thanks
TS
manishmodi
MemberQUOTE
06 April 2015 02:17PM Report Ignore #5
“Sakshi”
Super Star Member
[Moderator]
2585 total posts
Joined 31-Jul-2014
Profile PM
Mukesh Bhalse - 06 April 2015 11:55 AM
१। क्या तूफान में बहुत से पेड़ नहीं गिर गए थे?
—Had many trees not fallen down during the storm?
Did use hoga sakshi mam? ?
6anurag9
Memberwhat is ungrammatical?
6anurag9
Memberक्या तूफान में बहुत से पेड़ नहीं गिर गए थे?
gaye the toh did.
Did many trees not fall down in the storm?
TS
Memberक्या तूफान में बहुत से पेड़ नहीं गिर गए थे?
gaye the toh did.
Did many trees not fall down in the storm?
—- Had many trees not fallen down during the storm?
Regards
TS
manishmodi
Member@Ts
Kya tum market gaye the?
1. Had you gone to market?
—Did you go to the market?
Kya tumne electricity bill diya tha?
2.Had you given electricity bill?
—Did you give the electricity bill?
Because few teachers on this forum are saying it is right and few are saying it is wrong.
—No teacher is here but learner. If you follow the grammar rules, then you should not have asked this question. As per Past Perfect definition, 1 and 2 don’t fit there. I would rather say it ungrammatical than wrong.
Sakshi mam ne bhi did ko sahi btaya hai
Had is wrong
TS
Member@Ts
Kya tum market gaye the?
1. Had you gone to market?
—Did you go to the market?Kya tumne electricity bill diya tha?
2.Had you given electricity bill?
—Did you give the electricity bill?Because few teachers on this forum are saying it is right and few are saying it is wrong.
—No teacher is here but learner. If you follow the grammar rules, then you should not have asked this question. As per Past Perfect definition, 1 and 2 don’t fit there. I would rather say it ungrammatical than wrong.
Sakshi mam ne bhi did ko sahi btaya haiHad is wrong
My dear, You didn’t see @GV post..
plz check and reply.
Regards
TS
manishmodi
Member@Ts
I have seen Gv sir’s explanation but sakshi mam is saying did is right and Gv sir is saying had is right and devanampriya mam is also saying did is right
Please help me what should u do
TS
Member@Ts
I have seen Gv sir’s explanation but sakshi mam is saying did is right and Gv sir is saying had is right and devanampriya mam bhi
Please help me
Don’t get confused. Both are right according to me. Because English is a very flexible langugage.
Regards
TS
manishmodi
MemberBut sir maine ye sentence ek foreign site hai uss par pucha tha and waha ke teacher ne did ko sahi btaya hai
TS
MemberBut sir maine ye sentence ek foreign site hai uss par pucha tha and waha ke teacher ne did ko sahi btaya hai
I am also telling it is right..
Please read this carefully..
If two actions heppened in past, we have to see which action happened earlier than the other. In earlier action, We use Past Perfect form and in the later we use Simple Past Tense.
=====He had left his house when I reached there.
=====He had paid his dues before we asked him to do so.
I hope, this will help you.
Regards
TS
Devanampriya Priyadharshi
MemberBut sir maine ye sentence ek foreign site hai uss par pucha tha and waha ke teacher ne did ko sahi btaya hai
I guess, you are on the right track! Keep it up!
manishmodi
Member@Ts
I know this concept since class 6th
=====He had left his house when I reached there.
=====He paid his dues before we asked him to do so.
In above sentence two actions are present
But
Had you gone to the market
Iss me ek hi action hai dosara kaha hai???